Dad who left ‘at least’ 6 bite marks on newborn he called ‘ungrateful’ and ‘evil’ is sentenced


Gavan Rogers (Boone County Sheriff's Office)

Gavan Rogers (Boone County Sheriff’s Office)

A 26-year-old father in Indiana was sentenced last week after admitting to biting his newborn daughter multiple times, leaving “mouth-shaped bruises” and teeth marks all over the infant’s body. Boone County Circuit Court Judge Lori N. Schein on Thursday sentenced Gavan Rogers to three years at the Indiana Department of Corrections after he pleaded guilty to one count of felony domestic battery resulting in bodily injury to a person less than 14 years of age, court documents reviewed by Law&Crime show.

However, Schein ordered that Rogers serve less than a year behind bars, beginning his sentence with three months at the Boone County Jail, then serving nine months at Boone County Community Corrections — a supervised work-release program that is an alternative to incarceration — and serving the final two years on supervised probation. He was also credited with four days of time already served.

In exchange for pleading guilty, prosecutors agreed to drop one count of neglect of a dependent resulting in bodily injury.

As previously reported by Law&Crime, Rogers and the baby’s mother brought their 2-week-old daughter to Witham Hospital in Lebanon, Indiana, on Nov. 3, 2022, for a regularly scheduled checkup. The facility is about 30 miles northwest of Indianapolis.

Shortly after arriving at the facility, hospital staffers told authorities they discovered suspicious bruising on the baby’s forearms, stomach, shoulders, knee, and leg, police wrote in a probable cause affidavit obtained by Law&Crime.

The staff transferred the infant to Riley Hospital for Children in Indianapolis and contacted the Whitestown Police Department.

A doctor at the children’s hospital reported that the little girl appeared to have multiple bruises, several of which included visible teeth marks.

Upon arriving at the children’s hospital, the detective learned that after the baby’s birth at Witham Hospital, several nurses filed disturbing reports saying they overheard Rogers “making aggressive and offensive comments about his daughter, to his daughter,” the affidavit states. Such comments allegedly included Rogers referring to the baby as “evil,” and calling her a “little b—-” and “ungrateful” when the child was in the neonatal intensive care unit.

A few days later, the same nurse again allegedly witnessed an alarming interaction between Rogers and his baby, writing that she saw a “distinct difference” in the child’s behavior when being handled by Rogers as opposed to the baby’s mother.

“Another time in the room, (Rogers) had the baby completely undressed and laying in his lap. The baby was physically cold and crying while he watched and recorded videos of her crying,” the affidavit states. “I am not comfortable sending this baby home to the care of (Rogers).”

The Witham nursing staff also noted that Rogers seemed to get especially frustrated when his daughter cried and took extra time to explain the danger posed by shaking the baby.

In an interview with a Whitestown police detective, Rogers said he had been staying with the baby and her mother in Whitestown for the last two weeks, but normally lives with his parents in Greencastle, located about 50 miles southwest of Whitestown.

When asked about his daughter’s injuries, Rogers told allegedly hospital workers that he likely “open-mouth kissed” or “play bit” the infant with too much force. He later told the detective that he must have “nibbled too hard” on the child when she was fully clothed.

The detective on the scene wrote that he counted what appeared to be “at least six” bite marks on the newborn.

“These injuries could only have been inflicted while using excessive force, which would have caused severe pain to the (newborn),” the affidavit states.

Per the court’s order, Rogers was required to report to the Boone County Jail to begin his sentence by 6 p.m. on Monday, April 1.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *